Details
-
Change Request
-
Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
-
Medium
-
National Directory of Healthcare Providers and Services (NDH) (FHIR)
-
1.0.0-ballot
-
Patient Administration
-
STU
-
Exchange Use Cases
-
3.6
-
-
Bob Dieterle / David Pike : 6-0-0
-
Clarification
-
Non-substantive
Description
We appreciate NDH's inclusion of IHE profiling and work in the mCSD profile and Topologies whitepaper in the section on discovery of endpoints: 3.6 Discovery a HIE Endpoint via the NDH. Please make the following corrections:
- Please reference the IHE Topologies whitepaper (https://profiles.ihe.net/ITI/papers/Topologies/index.html), as it provides essential guidance for accomplishing this use case. Key sections:
- 4.2.2 Indicating Document Sharing Connectivity describes the meanings of the codes HIEInitiator and HIEResponder
- 4.2.6 Directory Perspective https://profiles.ihe.net/ITI/papers/Topologies/index.html#426-directory-perspective walks through representing a multi-level network
- 5.1.8 Document Access: Putting it all together shows an example with all the IHE profiling.
- The organizations 1.3.4 and 2.4.1 are not specific to Sutter, they represent the entire exchanges TEFCA and Carequality respectively. This is critical to the discovery approach; if interested in members of an HIE, start with the organization for that HIE and search for OrganizationAffiliations with the code HIEResponder. The full algorithm for discovering an endpoint is here: https://profiles.ihe.net/ITI/papers/Topologies/index.html#4242-service-provider-endpoint-discovery-algorithm
- There is another part to this, which is discovering whether an organization is eligible to act as a client in an HIE. This is done with the code HIEInitiator. Please add this.
- There is another part to this, which is discovering when an organization is reachable electronically, but only indirectly, through the endpoint of a related organization. This is the case with numerous IHE profiles for federated SOAP APIs like XCPD and XCA, and is indicated with the code DocShare-federate, defined in IHE mCSD. Please add this.
- Note that with these methods for HIE Endpoint discovery, for HIEs that manage private PKIs (e.g. eHealth Exchange, Carequality, DirectTrust and TEFCA) there is no need for the Endpoint.trust-framework extension, so please make that clear in guidance. Organizations already have the public certificates through HIE onboarding; this is not something they discover at runtime. See this discussion: https://chat.fhir.org/#narrow/stream/283066-united-states.2Fnational-directory/topic/Requirements.20for.20trust.20communities.2Fframeworks
- There are numerous typos, e.g. "Endpoinhts", "prfiled", "Discovery a HIE Endpoint"
Attachments
Issue Links
- is voted on by
-
BALLOT-52307 Negative - Joseph M. Lamy : 2023-Sep-FHIR IG NDH R1 STU
- Balloted
- relates to
-
FHIR-42652 Please use IHE Endpoint connection types
- Resolved - change required
-
FHIR-42902 Please incorporate IHE Topologies profiling for HIE Initiators
- Applied
-
FHIR-42903 Please incorporate IHE Topologies profiling for discovering federated (i.e. indirect) electronic routes
- Applied
-
FHIR-42646 Please document use cases for NDH Trust Framework extension
- Resolved - change required
-
FHIR-41772 The profile for Practitioner includes an extension for Endpoint, but should not.
- Resolved - No Change