Details
-
Change Request
-
Resolution: Not Persuasive with Modification
-
Medium
-
FHIR R5 Subscriptions Backport (FHIR)
-
FHIR Infrastructure
-
STU
-
Conformance
-
-
Clarification
-
Non-substantive
Description
In many cases, I expect the coordination between client and server on which SubscriptionTopic to support will be done at dev time, not at run time. I.e., a server would publish a list of topic canonicals they support, along with documentation online somewhere. A client will consume that documentation, and write code to work with the topics they care about.
In this case, SubscriptionTopic.read and search seem unnecessary for a server to support.
Additionally, a client that is doing development to support specific types of topics likely won't have authorization (an access token) to query the FHIR server SubscriptionTopics. Or at least not the production FHIR server. They might query a non-PRD or sandbox server to get topics during dev, but that would not be the same server they'd be interreacting with in PRD.
In short, I think the SubscriptionTopic discovery workflow as proposed doesn't feel real-world (or at least it won't be for all implementers, i.e., EHRs). And the subscriptions framework page should at a minimum allow for dev-time topic discovery by relaxing the run-time conformance requirements on servers in https://hl7.org/fhir/uv/subscriptions-backport/2024Jan/conformance.html
Attachments
Issue Links
- is voted on by
-
BALLOT-58169 Negative - Christopher Schaut : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59180 Negative - Vassil Peytchev : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59204 Negative - Kimberly Herman : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59218 Negative - Daniel Rutz : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59243 Negative - Danielle Friend : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59257 Negative - Cooper Thompson : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59271 Negative - David Sundaram-Stukel : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59319 Negative - Chris Courville : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
-
BALLOT-59333 Negative - Amit Popat : 2024-Jan-FHIR IG R5 SUBSCR 2R4 R1 STU
- Balloted
- relates to
-
FHIR-43613 Apply Subscription changes from backport IG ballot to FHIR Core
- Triaged