Uploaded image for project: 'FHIR Specification Feedback'
  1. FHIR Specification Feedback
  2. FHIR-42130

USCDI - FHIR US Core Relationship Clarification

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Icon: Change Request Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
    • Icon: Medium Medium
    • US Core (FHIR)
    • 6.1.0
    • Cross-Group Projects
    • USCDI
    • Hide

      Combined resolution with FHIR-42801 

      Update the introduction to the USCDI page to include the following:

      • State that this table is mapping table between USCDI data elements and USCore profiles
      • rationale. (per chatGPT): "ONC's USCDI and FHIR US Core are complementary initiatives, with USCDI defining high-level data requirements and FHIR US Core providing detailed FHIR-based profiles for meeting those requirements. Mapping between them is necessary for achieving interoperability and consistency in healthcare data exchange within the United States.")
      • keep some of the existing background text
      • FHIR US Core is based on community input and used for USCDI  ONC certification.
      • US Core audience includes certifiers and certification testers
      • Assert that US Core is broader than USCDI and that Certification is a merging of USCDI and US Core, and therefore, to make USCDI implementable in FHIR, interpretation of USCDI is necessary. 
      • USCDI data classes and element names may not be the same as the FHIR US Core resource names and element names 
      • We encourage our audience to submit questions and feedback to US Core specifications by clicking on the Propose a change link in the footer of every page.
      • We encourage our audience to request necessary clarifications to USCDI through the USCDI ONDEC process [USCDI ONDEC | Interoperability Standards Advisory (ISA) (healthit.gov)|https://www.healthit.gov/isa/ONDEC] that will inform future updates to FHIR US Core.
      Show
      Combined resolution with FHIR-42801   Update the introduction to the USCDI page to include the following: State that this table is mapping table between USCDI data elements and USCore profiles rationale. (per chatGPT): "ONC's USCDI and FHIR US Core are complementary initiatives, with USCDI defining high-level data requirements and FHIR US Core providing detailed FHIR-based profiles for meeting those requirements. Mapping between them is necessary for achieving interoperability and consistency in healthcare data exchange within the United States.") keep some of the existing background text FHIR US Core is based on community input and used for USCDI  ONC certification. US Core audience includes certifiers and certification testers Assert that US Core is broader than USCDI and that Certification is a merging of USCDI and US Core, and therefore, to make USCDI implementable in FHIR, interpretation of USCDI is necessary.  USCDI data classes and element names may not be the same as the FHIR US Core resource names and element names  We encourage our audience to submit questions and feedback to US Core specifications by clicking on the Propose a change link in the footer of every page. We encourage our audience to request necessary clarifications to USCDI through the USCDI ONDEC process [USCDI ONDEC | Interoperability Standards Advisory (ISA) (healthit.gov)|https://www.healthit.gov/isa/ONDEC]  that will inform future updates to FHIR US Core.
    • Eric Haas/Brett Marquard: 17-0-0
    • Clarification
    • Non-substantive

    Description

      Considering the ambiguity of USCDI data classes and data elements and recognizing that the allocation of data elements to data classes based on the actual individual data element's definition, one cannot draw a straight line from USCDI terminology to corresponding FHIR US Core terminology.  Since FHIR US Core is used for certification, while USCDI is used in general industry discussions, a reader of USCDI may anticipate more or different capabilities in their certified HIT when not familiar with FHIR US Core and that FHIR US Core is an interpretation and possibly a subset of one may believe or understand that USCDI is intended to cover.

      In the absence of more clarity and less ambiguity in USCDI that can provide a straight-line navigation and interpretation of FHIR US Core, thus what is actually being certified, we suggest that the USCDI page is updated to clearly state that:

      • FHIR US Core is used for certification and that any variances in interpretation of USCDI are intended to be resolved and reflected in FHIR US Core.
      • that in that process, data elements listed in certain data classes may not appear in a FHIR US Core resource of the same name used for the data class in USCDI.
      • or that data classes in USCDI may appear to have a wider scope than the similarly named FHIR resource.
      • and that other resources that might by some to be interpreted as a type or category of a USCDI data class are not yet represented in FHIR US Core until USCDI more explicitly expresses that intended scope.
      • we therefore encourage to request necessary clarifications to USCDI through the USCDI ONDEC process [USCDI ONDEC | Interoperability Standards Advisory (ISA) (healthit.gov)|https://www.healthit.gov/isa/ONDEC] that will inform future updates to FHIR US Core.

      We should also consider whether the same language should be provided as part of the disposition in the corresponding CDA C-CDA CG version while C-CDA documents are intended to remain in sync with FHIR US Core data content.

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            Unassigned Unassigned
            hbuitendijk Hans Buitendijk
            Hans Buitendijk
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: