Uploaded image for project: 'FHIR Specification Feedback'
  1. FHIR Specification Feedback
  2. FHIR-42009

NutritionIntake profile should more closely address the FHIR R5 NutritionIntake modeling

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Icon: Change Request Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive
    • Icon: Highest Highest
    • US QI Core (FHIR)
    • 6.0.0-ballot
    • Clinical Quality Information
    • STU
    • Nutrition Intake example [deprecated]
      QICore Nutrition Intake [deprecated]
    • QI-Core Profiles
    • Hide

      QI-Core will remove the NutritionIntake profile since there is still no clarity regarding the use case the resource is trying to address which seems to be related to dietary department software interoperability with the EHR and not EHR to EHR (direct communication from resource developers). Also remove the NutritionIntake example from the QI-Core 6.0 ballot version and the example value set.

      Will discuss with measure developers the benefit of creating authoring patterns using SimpleObservation as guidance for measure developers (but not part of the QI-Core IG)

      See also FHIR-42158 and FHIR-42154
       

      Show
      QI-Core will remove the NutritionIntake profile since there is still no clarity regarding the use case the resource is trying to address which seems to be related to dietary department software interoperability with the EHR and not EHR to EHR (direct communication from resource developers). Also remove the NutritionIntake example from the QI-Core 6.0 ballot version and the example value set. Will discuss with measure developers the benefit of creating authoring patterns using SimpleObservation as guidance for measure developers (but not part of the QI-Core IG) See also FHIR-42158 and FHIR-42154  
    • Bryn Rhodes/ Floyd Eisenberg: 23-0-0
    • Correction
    • Compatible, substantive

    Description

      The QI-Core NutritionIntake profile identifies the food item as code with example binding to  Example Foods (example). This element is problematic for two reasons:

      1) QI-Core has traditionally required binding to an existing value set with minimum binding of preferred rather than example, and, moreover, expressly avoids binding to a value set with example in its title. This modeling is inconsistent.

      2) The intended modeling was to be consistent with the Orders and Observation resource in FHIR R5 [NutritionIntake|https://hl7.org/fhir/nutritionintake.html].  That resource specifically uses code element to indicate "Code representing an overall type of nutrition intake
      Binding: Diet Codes (Example)". This is an example binding but it references diets, not individual dietary elements.  It would be appropriate to use QI-Core NutritionIntake.code to reference the same concept in parallel and bind to a value set of possible diets. However, seems inappropriate to bind to individual nutritional elements.  The FHIR R5 resource specifically addresses items as consumedItem (What food or fluid product or item was consumed) and consumedItem.type (The type of food or fluid product) with binding: Types of Edible Substances (Example). While the value set is considered experimental, it is relatively comprehensive and it addresses the concepts requested by measure developers that led to the creation of the QI-Core profile.

       

      Recommend that the profile be modified to include .code to reference a diet (but not must support and cardinality 0..1, AND to include .consumedItem and consumedItem.type. The value set binding may need to be preferred and bind to a value set similar to that presented as types of edible substances created in VSAC, or ideally, to a value set published in THO by OO for this purpose.  Note that the experimental value set includes >1000 codes and includes two codes that would support the original measure developer request:

        226789007 http://snomed.info/sct Breast milk
        226790003 http://snomed.info/sct EBM - Expressed breast milk

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            jen_seeman Jennifer Seeman
            feisenberg Floyd Eisenberg
            Floyd Eisenberg
            Watchers:
            6 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: