Uploaded image for project: 'FHIR Specification Feedback'
  1. FHIR Specification Feedback
  2. FHIR-41503

Binding should be extensible in most codes of Radiotherapy Course Summary

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Icon: Change Request Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
    • Icon: Medium Medium
    • US Minimal Common Oncology Data Elements (mCODE) (FHIR)
    • 2.1.0
    • Clinical Interoperability Council
    • Procedure Intent Extension
      Radiotherapy Course Summary Profile
      Radiotherapy Modality Extension
      Radiotherapy Technique Extension
      Radiotherapy Volume Profile
      Treatment Termination Reason Extension (deprecated)
    • Hide

      The following bindings have been made extensible:

      • Extension: TreatmentTerminationReason
      • Extension: ProcedureIntent
      • Profile: RadiotherapyCourseSummary , element Procedure.bodySite
      • Profile: RadiotherapyVolume BodyStructure.location

      A set of invariants link the following elements, to ensure that only valid combinations are used: * Extension: RadiotherapyModalityAndTechnique element modality

      • Extension: RadiotherapyModalityAndTechnique element technique

       
      To achieve the flexibility of an extensible binding yet maintain the utility of the invariants, the value sets bound to these elements have been extended with an 'un-codeable' value, and additional invariants require that the .text field be specified when the 'un-codeable' value is used.

      Show
      The following bindings have been made extensible: Extension: TreatmentTerminationReason Extension: ProcedureIntent Profile: RadiotherapyCourseSummary , element Procedure.bodySite Profile: RadiotherapyVolume BodyStructure.location A set of invariants link the following elements, to ensure that only valid combinations are used: * Extension: RadiotherapyModalityAndTechnique element modality Extension: RadiotherapyModalityAndTechnique element technique   To achieve the flexibility of an extensible binding yet maintain the utility of the invariants, the value sets bound to these elements have been extended with an 'un-codeable' value, and additional invariants require that the .text field be specified when the 'un-codeable' value is used.
    • D Pyke / M Kramer : 11-0-0
    • Correction
    • Compatible, substantive
    • current

    Description

      The binding of below data elements should be changed from required to extensible, such that in cases where mapping to SNOMED CT fails, the data still can be retained in mCODE defined extensions and we can avoid losing the data or using proprietary extensions in parallel.

      Extension: TreatmentTerminationReason

      Extension: ProcedureIntent

      Profile:  RadiotherapyCourseSummary , element Procedure.bodySite

      Extension: RadiotherapyModalityAndTechnique element modality

      Extension: RadiotherapyModalityAndTechnique element technique

      Profile: RadiotherapyVolume BodyStructure.location

      Implementation and testing in three IHE-RO workshops 2022, 2023 with multiple vendors has shown that practical radiotherapy systems cannot map all existing data to the required ValueSets of mCODE. Some values can be mapped and generally mCODE Radiotherapy profiles were successfully used. But in some cases the mapping to SOMED CT is not reliably possible, and changing the software at customer sites to capture the data differently can take many years. FHIR interfaces can be added much quicker, but may need to be more flexible to allow imperfectly encoded data. To pass mCODE validation, systems would currently have to completely drop these data elements or use proprietary extensions in parallel. Vendors in IHE-RO discussed and agreed to rather keep data in a form that can be interpreted by humans or a subset of systems that loosing the data.

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            Unassigned Unassigned
            mvonsieb Martin von Siebenthal
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: