Uploaded image for project: 'FHIR Specification Feedback'
  1. FHIR Specification Feedback
  2. FHIR-41475

Adjust QI-Core Observation must supports

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Icon: Change Request Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
    • Icon: Medium Medium
    • US QI Core (FHIR)
    • current
    • Clinical Quality Information
    • QICore Observation [deprecated]
    • Hide

      Update to new US Core profile Simple Observation. Note that, unless the element has a MS flag in US Core 6.1.0, we should include those Keep element in the Key Elements Table for QICore but not add an MS Flag. Add (QM) to description of all Keep or Add elements such that that will be included in the Key Elements Table for QI-Core.

      QI-Core Profile-based Path Action Include in QI-Core 6.0 Justification
      Observation.implicitRules Keep YES As in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation
      Observaton.bodyPosition REMOVE NO No use in existing eCQMs
      Observation.modifierExtension Keep YES As in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation
      Observation.basedOn REMOVE NO No use in existing eCQMs
      Observation.status Keep YES USCDI – Import US Core Simple Observation Profile and modify value set binding to required Non-Negative Observation Status. This is a subset of the required US Core binding value set removing the cancelled option to allow a disjoint with QICoreObservationCancelled.
      QICoreObservation.category Keep YES USCDI – Import US Core Simple Observation Profile; slices for category with preferred binding to ObservationCategoryCodes; category:us-core with required binding to US Core Simple Observation Category
      QICoreObservation.code Keep YES USCDI – Import US Core Simple Observation Profile and its preferred  binding to LOINCCodes.  This is not a change from QI-Core Observation Survey profile
      QICoreObservation.subject Keep YES (modify reference) USCDI – Modify reference from US Core Simple Observation Profile to refer to QI-CorePatient
      QICoreObservaton.encounter REMOVE NO Not in US Core and eCQMs use CQL expressions to identify relationship of encounters to observations
      QICoreObservation.[effective[x] http://hl7.org/fhir/us/qicore/STU5/StructureDefinition-qicore-observation-lab-definitions.html#key_Observation.effective[x]] Keep YES USCDI –US Core effectiveDateTime using datatype dateTime; RETAIN QI-Core options for effectivePeriod, effectiveTiming, effectiveInstant
      Observation.issued REMOVE NO The only use case for reported (issued) time is in laboratory tests.
      QICoreObservation.performer Keep YES USCDI – US Core references USCorePractitioner, USCoreOrganization, USCorePatient, USCorePractitionerRole, USCoreCareTeam, USCoreRelatedPerson.  Change references to QICorePractitioner, QICoreOrganization, QICorePatient, QICorePractitionerRole, QICoreCareTeam, QICoreRelatedPerson.
      QICoreObservation.[value[x] http://hl7.org/fhir/us/qicore/STU5/StructureDefinition-qicore-observation-lab-definitions.html#key_Observation.value[x]] Keep YES USCDI – not US Core notation SHOULD use SNOMED CT for coded results.
      Also, US Core limited values to Quantity, Codeable Concept, ValueString.  Continue to include valueBoolean, valueInteger, valueRange, valueRatio, valueTime, valueDateTime, valuePeriod
      QICoreObservation.value[x].[value[x]CodeableConcept http://hl7.org/fhir/us/qicore/STU5/StructureDefinition-qicore-observation-definitions.html#key_Observation.value[x]:valueCodeableConcept] Keep YES Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation
      QICoreObservation.dataAbsentReason REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs
      QICoreObservation.interpretation Keep YES Not included in US Core/USCDI but has value similar to lab tests as discovered by eCQM community. Retain extensible binding to ObservationInterpretationCodes
      QIObservation.bodySite REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs
      QICoreObservation.method REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs
      QICoreObservation.Specimen REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs
      QICoreObservation.device REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs
      QICoreObservation.referenceRange REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs
      QICoreObservation.derivedFrom Keep YES USCDI – US Core references Observation, US Core DocumentReference, US Core QuestionnaireResponse, ImagingStudy, Media, MolecularSequence, change to QICore SimpleObservation, QICore DocumentReference, QICore QuestionnaireResponse, QICoreImagingStudy, Media, Molecular Sequence
      QICoreObservation.component REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs

       

      Show
      Update to new US Core profile Simple Observation. Note that, unless the element has a MS flag in US Core 6.1.0, we should include those Keep element in the Key Elements Table for QICore but not add an MS Flag. Add (QM) to description of all Keep or Add elements such that that will be included in the Key Elements Table for QI-Core. QI-Core Profile-based Path Action Include in QI-Core 6.0 Justification Observation. implicitRules Keep YES As in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation Observaton. bodyPosition REMOVE NO No use in existing eCQMs Observation. modifierExtension Keep YES As in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation Observation. basedOn REMOVE NO No use in existing eCQMs Observation. status Keep YES USCDI – Import US Core Simple Observation Profile and modify value set binding to required Non-Negative Observation Status . This is a subset of the required US Core binding value set removing the cancelled option to allow a disjoint with QICoreObservationCancelled. QICoreObservation. category Keep YES USCDI – Import US Core Simple Observation Profile; slices for category with preferred binding to ObservationCategoryCodes ; category:us-core with required binding to US Core Simple Observation Category QICoreObservation. code Keep YES USCDI – Import US Core Simple Observation Profile and its preferred  binding to LOINCCode s.  This is not a change from QI-Core Observation Survey profile QICoreObservation. subject Keep YES (modify reference) USCDI – Modify reference from US Core Simple Observation Profile to refer to QI-CorePatient QICoreObservaton. encounter REMOVE NO Not in US Core and eCQMs use CQL expressions to identify relationship of encounters to observations QICoreObservation.[effective [x] http://hl7.org/fhir/us/qicore/STU5/StructureDefinition-qicore-observation-lab-definitions.html#key_Observation.effective[x]] Keep YES USCDI –US Core effectiveDateTime using datatype dateTime; RETAIN QI-Core options for effectivePeriod, effectiveTiming, effectiveInstant Observation. issued REMOVE NO The only use case for reported (issued) time is in laboratory tests. QICoreObservation. performer Keep YES USCDI – US Core references USCorePractitioner, USCoreOrganization, USCorePatient, USCorePractitionerRole, USCoreCareTeam, USCoreRelatedPerson.  Change references to QICorePractitioner, QICoreOrganization, QICorePatient, QICorePractitionerRole, QICoreCareTeam, QICoreRelatedPerson. QICoreObservation.[value [x] http://hl7.org/fhir/us/qicore/STU5/StructureDefinition-qicore-observation-lab-definitions.html#key_Observation.value[x]] Keep YES USCDI – not US Core notation SHOULD use SNOMED CT for coded results. Also, US Core limited values to Quantity, Codeable Concept, ValueString.  Continue to include valueBoolean, valueInteger, valueRange, valueRatio, valueTime, valueDateTime, valuePeriod QICoreObservation.value [x] .[value [x] CodeableConcept http://hl7.org/fhir/us/qicore/STU5/StructureDefinition-qicore-observation-definitions.html#key_Observation.value[x]:valueCodeableConcept] Keep YES Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation QICoreObservation. dataAbsentReason REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs QICoreObservation. interpretation Keep YES Not included in US Core/USCDI but has value similar to lab tests as discovered by eCQM community. Retain extensible binding to ObservationInterpretationCodes QIObservation. bodySite REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs QICoreObservation. method REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs QICoreObservation. Specimen REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs QICoreObservation. device REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs QICoreObservation. referenceRange REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs QICoreObservation. derivedFrom Keep YES USCDI – US Core references Observation, US Core DocumentReference, US Core QuestionnaireResponse, ImagingStudy, Media, MolecularSequence, change to QICore SimpleObservation, QICore DocumentReference, QICore QuestionnaireResponse, QICoreImagingStudy, Media, Molecular Sequence QICoreObservation. component REMOVE NO Not listed in US Core 6.1.0 Simple Observation or used in eCQMs  
    • Floyd Eisenberg/Jen Seeman: 24-0-0
    • Enhancement
    • Non-compatible

    Description

      Adjust the set of Must Support elements for this profile based on the rationale in tracker FHIR-41340

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            jen_seeman Jennifer Seeman
            karlnaden Karl Naden
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: