Details
-
Change Request
-
Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
-
Highest
-
US Core (FHIR)
-
6.0.0-ballot [deprecated]
-
Cross-Group Projects
-
STU
-
Screening and Assessments
-
3.6.2.3
-
-
Eric Haas / Jason Vogt : 13-0-0
-
Clarification
-
Compatible, substantive
-
Yes
Description
This section indicates the rationale for using Observations instead of QuestionnaireResponse.
FHIR, for very good reasons, choose to separate the template in which to gather data (Questionnaire) from the answers (QuestionnaireResponse) and the resulting clinical resources (Observations and others).
The rationale given by US core indicates that US core wants to document the clinical results of specific questionnaires as clinical Observations. This is valid and the structure defined by US core for doing so can be used for this purpose.
The current text leans towards disallowing the use of Questionnaire and QuestionnaireResponse in US core compatible systems. I think this is one step to far.
I propose that US core states that it specifies/defines the way that the results (answers) to the questionnaires who's support is required by US core are stored. This would be the Observation resources.
US core should leave open whether the source questions and answers are stored using Questionnaire and QuestionnaireResponse resources for systems that choose to do so.
Attachments
Issue Links
- is voted on by
-
BALLOT-46218 Negative - Bas van den Heuvel : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-46855 Negative - Javier Espina : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-46895 Negative - Lisson Zhang : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-46912 Negative - Peter Kranich : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-46929 Negative - David Simons : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-47027 Negative - Chris Melo : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-47103 Negative - Pepijn Wortelboer : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-46838 Negative - Vadim Peretokin : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Closed
-
BALLOT-47010 Negative - Bert Roos : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Closed
-
BALLOT-47130 Negative - Martin Rosner : 2023-Jan-FHIR US CORE R5.1.0 STU
- Closed
- relates to
-
FHIR-39495 Disagree with removing QuestionnaireResponse
- Published