Uploaded image for project: 'FHIR Specification Feedback'
  1. FHIR Specification Feedback
  2. FHIR-38044

Update detail around Ask At Order Entry (AOE) questions

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Icon: Change Request Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive
    • Icon: Medium Medium
    • At-Home In-Vitro Test Report (FHIR)
    • 1.0.0-ballot
    • Orders & Observations
    • STU
    • Workflow
    • Hide

      Will update as suggested (with a few minor grammar/spelling tweaks, plus adding back the mention of choice of the supportingInformation FHIR extension) as follows:

      "These questions are not considered the same as “Ask at Order Entry” (AOE) questions by lab standards experts because:

      • the answers to the questions do not affect the interpretation of the positive or negative result
      • they are there to support Public Health (PH) response

      This solution of representing the information with the supportingInformation FHIR Extension was chosen during the pandemic as it is a supported way for laboratories to add information to their LIS and subsequently send it out. There was a lot of discussion and long-term this information should be coming from other systems to PH, so the lab does not need to store information just for the sake of forwarding it. For this At-Home Test use case that might be an option, so for this use case it may remain the solution (or it may need to be revisited)."

      Show
      Will update as suggested (with a few minor grammar/spelling tweaks, plus adding back the mention of choice of the supportingInformation FHIR extension) as follows: "These questions are not considered the same as “Ask at Order Entry” (AOE) questions by lab standards experts because: the answers to the questions do not affect the interpretation of the positive or negative result they are there to support Public Health (PH) response This solution of representing the information with the supportingInformation FHIR Extension was chosen during the pandemic as it is a supported way for laboratories to add information to their LIS and subsequently send it out. There was a lot of discussion and long-term this information should be coming from other systems to PH, so the lab does not need to store information just for the sake of forwarding it. For this At-Home Test use case that might be an option, so for this use case it may remain the solution (or it may need to be revisited)."
    • Sarah Gaunt / Elliot Silver : 17 - 3 - 0
    • Clarification
    • Non-substantive

    Description

      Current Text: These questions are not considered the same as “Ask at Order Entry” (AOE) questions by lab standards experts because:

      • there may not be an order
      • the answers to the questions do not affect the interpretation of the postive or negative result
      • it was determined that for public health departments’ receiving and storing data, it is best to be consistent and represent this information with the supportingInformation FHIR Extension.

       

      I like that you are pointing out that these are NOT like AOEs, but I think we should split out why they are not AOEs from why we are currently representing them this way.

      Suggested new text:

      These questions are not considered the same as “Ask at Order Entry” (AOE) questions by lab standards experts because:

      • the answers to the questions do not affect the interpretation of the postive or negative result
      • they are there to support Public Health response

      This solution was chosen during the pandemic as that is a supported way for laboratories to add information to their LIS and then subsequently send it out. There was a lot of discussion and long-term this information should be coming from other systems to PH, so the lab does not need to store information just for the sake of forwarding it. For this At-Home Test use case that might be an option, so for this use case it may remain the solution (or it may need to be revisted).

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            minigrrl Sarah Gaunt
            RikiM Ulrike Merrick
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: