Uploaded image for project: 'FHIR Specification Feedback'
  1. FHIR Specification Feedback
  2. FHIR-35077

Inconsistent profile names

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Icon: Change Request Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive
    • Icon: Highest Highest
    • US PACIO Advance Directive Interoperability (FHIR)
    • 0.1.0
    • Patient Empowerment
    • STU
    • FHIR Artifacts
      Home
    • Hide

      Update the spec with all artifact titles/names/ids using the following convention (except for Example resources):

       

      Title: ADI {Resource Name}[ {[for ]Use Context}]
      Name: ADI{ResourceType}[{Use Context}]
      ID: ADI-{ResourceType}[-{Use Context}]
      

      The following are proposed names:

       
      ************

      Old Name Old ID Old Title New Name New ID New Title:
      PADI CapabilityStatement padi PADI CapabilityStatement ADICapabilityStatement ADI-CapabilityStatement ADI Capability Statement
      PADIGoal PADI-Goal ADI Goal ADIGoal ADI-Goal ADI Goal
      PADIHeader PADI-Header PACIO ADI Header ADICompositionHeader ADI-Composition-Header ADI Composition Header
      PADIAutopsyObservation PADI-AutopsyObservation ADI Autopsy Observation ADIObservationAutopsy ADI-Observation-Autopsy ADI Observation for Autopsy
      PADICareExperiencePreference PADI-CareExperiencePreference ADI Care Experience Preference ADIGoalCareExperiencePreference ADI-Goal-CareExperiencePreference ADI Goal for Care Experience Preference
      PADIDocumentReference PADI-DocumentReference PACIO ADI Document Reference ADIDocumentReference ADI-DocumentReference ADI Document Reference
      PADIDocumentationObservation PADI-DocumentationObservation ADI Documentation Observation ADIObservationExistingDocumentation ADI-Observation-ExistingDocumentation ADI Observation for Existing Documentation
      PADIOrganDonationObservation PADI-OrganDonationObservation ADI Organ Donation ADIObservationOrganDonation ADI-Observation-OrganDonation ADI Observation for OrganDonation
      PADIPACPComposition PADI-PACPComposition ADI Personal Advance Care Plan Composition ADICompositionPersonalAdvanceCarePlan ADI-Composition-PersonalAdvanceCarePlan ADI Composition for Personal Advance Care Plan
      PADIParticipant PADI-Participant ADI Participant ADIRelatedPersonParticipant ADI-RelatedPerson-Participant ADI Related Person Participant
      PADIParticipantConsent PADI-ParticipantConsent ADI Participant Consent ADIConsentParticipant ADI-Consent-Participant ADI Consent Participant
      PADIPersonalGoal PADI-PersonalGoal ADI Personal Goal ADIGoalPersonalPreference ADI-Goal-PersonalPreference ADI Goal for Personal Preference
      PADIPersonalInterventionPreference PADI-PersonalInterventionPreference Personal Intervention Preference ADIGoalPersonalInterventionPreference ADI-Goal-PersonalInterventionPreference ADI Goal for Personal Intervention Preference
      PADIPersonalPrioritiesOrganizer PADI-PersonalPrioritiesOrganizer ADI Personal Priorities Organizer ADIListPersonalPrioritiesOrganizer ADI-List-PersonalPrioritiesOrganizer ADI List for Personal Priorities Organizer
      PADIPreferenceCarePlan PADI-PreferenceCarePlan ADI Preference Care Plan ADICarePlanPatientPreference ADI-CarePlan-PatientPreference ADI Care Plan for Patient Preference
      PADIProvenance PADI-Provenance PACIO ADI Provenance ADIProvenance ADI-Provenance ADI Provenance
      AttestationInformationExtension padi-attestationInformation-extension Attestation Information ADIExtensionAttestationInformation ADI-Extension-AttestationInformation ADI Extension for Attestation Information
      ClauseExtension padi-clause-extension Clause ADIExtensionClause ADI-Extension-Clause ADI Extension for Clause
      ContextualValueExtension padi-contextualValue-extension Contextual Value ADIExtensionContextualValue ADI-Extension-ContextualValue ADI Extension for Contextual Value
      EffectiveDateExtension padi-effective-date-extension Effective Date ADIExtensionEffectiveDate ADI-Extension-EffectiveDate ADI Extension for Effective Date
      GoalOrderByDescendingPriority padi-goal-order-by-descending-priority-extension Goal Order by Descending Priority ADIExtensionGoalByDescendingPriority ADI-Extension-GoalByDescendingPriority ADI Extension Goal By Descending Priority
      Jurisdiction padi-jurisdiction-extension Jurisdiction ADIExtensionJurisdiction ADI-Extension-Jurisdiction ADI Extension for Jurisdiction
      PADIAdvanceDirectiveCategoriesVS PADIAdvanceDirectiveCategoriesVS Advance Directive Categories ADIValueSetAdvanceDirectiveCategories ADI-ValueSet-AdvanceDirectiveCategories ADI Value Set for Advance Directive Categories
      PADIAttesterRoleTypeVS PADIAttesterRoleTypeVS Attester Role ADIValueSetAttesterRole ADI-ValueSet-AttesterRole ADI Value Set for Attester Role
      PADICareExperiencePreferencesVS PADICareExperiencePreferencesVS Care Experience Preferences ADIValueSetCareExperiencePreferences ADI-ValueSet-CareExperiencePreferences ADI Value Set for Care Experience Preferences
      PADIClauseTypeVS PADIClauseTypeVS Type of clause ADIValueSetClauseType ADI-ValueSet-ClauseType ADI Value Set for Clause Type
      PADIConsentActorRoleVS PADIConsentActorRoleVS ADI Consent Actor Role ADIValueSetConsentActorRole ADI-ValueSet-ConsentActorRole ADI Value Set for Consent Actor Role
      PADIConsentTypeVS PADIConsentTypeVS Consent Type ADIValueSetConsentType ADI-ValueSet-ConsentType ADI Value Set for Consent Type
      PADIDocumentationTypeVS PADIDocumentationTypeVS Documentation Types ADIValueSetDocumentationType ADI-ValueSet-DocumentationType ADI Value Set for Documentation Type
      PADIHCADecisionsVS PADIHCADecisionsVS Healthcare Agent Decisions ADIValueSetHealthcareAgentDecision ADI-ValueSet-HealthcareAgentDecision ADI Value Set for Healthcare Agent Decision
      PADIHealthGoalsVS PADIHealthGoalsVS Health Goals ADIValueSetHealthGoal ADI-ValueSet-HealthGoal ADI Value Set for Health Goal
      PADIInterventionPreferencesNarrativeVS PADIInterventionPreferencesNarrativeVS Intervention Preferences - Narrative ADIValueSetInterventionPreferenceNarrative ADI-ValueSet-InterventionPreferenceNarrative ADI Value Set for Intervention Preference Narrative
      PADIInterventionPreferencesOrdinalVS PADIInterventionPreferencesOrdinalVS Intervention Preferences - Ordinal ADIValueSetInterventionPreferenceOrdinal ADI-ValueSet-InterventionPreferenceOrdinal ADI Value Set for Intervention Preference Ordinal
      PADIInterventionPreferencesVS PADIInterventionPreferencesVS Intervention Preferences ADIValueSetInterventionPreference ADI-ValueSet-InterventionPreference ADI Value Set for Intervention Preference
      PADINoHealthcareAgentIncludedReasonVS PADINoHealthcareAgentIncludedReasonVS No Healthcare Agent Included Reason ADIValueSetNoHealthcareAgentIncludedReason ADI-ValueSet-NoHealthcareAgentIncludedReason ADI Value Set for No Healthcare Agent Included Reason
      PADIParticipantRelationshipVS PADIParticipantRelationshipVS Participant Relationships ADIValueSetParticipantRelationship ADI-ValueSet-ParticipantRelationship ADI Value Set for Participant Relationship
      PADIPersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleTypeVS PADIPersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleTypeVS Personal And Legal Relationship Role Type ADIValueSetPersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleType ADI-ValueSet-PersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleType ADI Value Set for Personal And Legal Relationship Role Type
      PADIUponDeathPreferencesVS PADIUponDeathPreferencesVS Upon Death Preferences ADIValueSetUponDeathPreferences ADI-ValueSet-UponDeathPreferences ADI Value Set for Upon Death Preferences
      eSystem/PADIGoalCategoryCS eSystem/PADIGoalCategoryCS ADI Goal Category Code System ADICodeSystemGoalCategory ADI-CodeSystem-GoalCategory ADI Code System for Goal Category
      PADIHCADecisionsCS PADIHCADecisionsCS Healthcare Agent Decision Codes ADICodeSystemHealthcareAgentDecision ADI-CodeSystem-HealthcareAgentDecision ADI Code System for Healthcare Agent Decision
      Show
      Update the spec with all artifact titles/names/ids using the following convention (except for Example resources):   Title: ADI {Resource Name}[ {[ for ]Use Context}] Name: ADI{ResourceType}[{Use Context}] ID: ADI-{ResourceType}[-{Use Context}] The following are proposed names:   ************ Old Name Old ID Old Title New Name New ID New Title: PADI CapabilityStatement padi PADI CapabilityStatement ADICapabilityStatement ADI-CapabilityStatement ADI Capability Statement PADIGoal PADI-Goal ADI Goal ADIGoal ADI-Goal ADI Goal PADIHeader PADI-Header PACIO ADI Header ADICompositionHeader ADI-Composition-Header ADI Composition Header PADIAutopsyObservation PADI-AutopsyObservation ADI Autopsy Observation ADIObservationAutopsy ADI-Observation-Autopsy ADI Observation for Autopsy PADICareExperiencePreference PADI-CareExperiencePreference ADI Care Experience Preference ADIGoalCareExperiencePreference ADI-Goal-CareExperiencePreference ADI Goal for Care Experience Preference PADIDocumentReference PADI-DocumentReference PACIO ADI Document Reference ADIDocumentReference ADI-DocumentReference ADI Document Reference PADIDocumentationObservation PADI-DocumentationObservation ADI Documentation Observation ADIObservationExistingDocumentation ADI-Observation-ExistingDocumentation ADI Observation for Existing Documentation PADIOrganDonationObservation PADI-OrganDonationObservation ADI Organ Donation ADIObservationOrganDonation ADI-Observation-OrganDonation ADI Observation for OrganDonation PADIPACPComposition PADI-PACPComposition ADI Personal Advance Care Plan Composition ADICompositionPersonalAdvanceCarePlan ADI-Composition-PersonalAdvanceCarePlan ADI Composition for Personal Advance Care Plan PADIParticipant PADI-Participant ADI Participant ADIRelatedPersonParticipant ADI-RelatedPerson-Participant ADI Related Person Participant PADIParticipantConsent PADI-ParticipantConsent ADI Participant Consent ADIConsentParticipant ADI-Consent-Participant ADI Consent Participant PADIPersonalGoal PADI-PersonalGoal ADI Personal Goal ADIGoalPersonalPreference ADI-Goal-PersonalPreference ADI Goal for Personal Preference PADIPersonalInterventionPreference PADI-PersonalInterventionPreference Personal Intervention Preference ADIGoalPersonalInterventionPreference ADI-Goal-PersonalInterventionPreference ADI Goal for Personal Intervention Preference PADIPersonalPrioritiesOrganizer PADI-PersonalPrioritiesOrganizer ADI Personal Priorities Organizer ADIListPersonalPrioritiesOrganizer ADI-List-PersonalPrioritiesOrganizer ADI List for Personal Priorities Organizer PADIPreferenceCarePlan PADI-PreferenceCarePlan ADI Preference Care Plan ADICarePlanPatientPreference ADI-CarePlan-PatientPreference ADI Care Plan for Patient Preference PADIProvenance PADI-Provenance PACIO ADI Provenance ADIProvenance ADI-Provenance ADI Provenance AttestationInformationExtension padi-attestationInformation-extension Attestation Information ADIExtensionAttestationInformation ADI-Extension-AttestationInformation ADI Extension for Attestation Information ClauseExtension padi-clause-extension Clause ADIExtensionClause ADI-Extension-Clause ADI Extension for Clause ContextualValueExtension padi-contextualValue-extension Contextual Value ADIExtensionContextualValue ADI-Extension-ContextualValue ADI Extension for Contextual Value EffectiveDateExtension padi-effective-date-extension Effective Date ADIExtensionEffectiveDate ADI-Extension-EffectiveDate ADI Extension for Effective Date GoalOrderByDescendingPriority padi-goal-order-by-descending-priority-extension Goal Order by Descending Priority ADIExtensionGoalByDescendingPriority ADI-Extension-GoalByDescendingPriority ADI Extension Goal By Descending Priority Jurisdiction padi-jurisdiction-extension Jurisdiction ADIExtensionJurisdiction ADI-Extension-Jurisdiction ADI Extension for Jurisdiction PADIAdvanceDirectiveCategoriesVS PADIAdvanceDirectiveCategoriesVS Advance Directive Categories ADIValueSetAdvanceDirectiveCategories ADI-ValueSet-AdvanceDirectiveCategories ADI Value Set for Advance Directive Categories PADIAttesterRoleTypeVS PADIAttesterRoleTypeVS Attester Role ADIValueSetAttesterRole ADI-ValueSet-AttesterRole ADI Value Set for Attester Role PADICareExperiencePreferencesVS PADICareExperiencePreferencesVS Care Experience Preferences ADIValueSetCareExperiencePreferences ADI-ValueSet-CareExperiencePreferences ADI Value Set for Care Experience Preferences PADIClauseTypeVS PADIClauseTypeVS Type of clause ADIValueSetClauseType ADI-ValueSet-ClauseType ADI Value Set for Clause Type PADIConsentActorRoleVS PADIConsentActorRoleVS ADI Consent Actor Role ADIValueSetConsentActorRole ADI-ValueSet-ConsentActorRole ADI Value Set for Consent Actor Role PADIConsentTypeVS PADIConsentTypeVS Consent Type ADIValueSetConsentType ADI-ValueSet-ConsentType ADI Value Set for Consent Type PADIDocumentationTypeVS PADIDocumentationTypeVS Documentation Types ADIValueSetDocumentationType ADI-ValueSet-DocumentationType ADI Value Set for Documentation Type PADIHCADecisionsVS PADIHCADecisionsVS Healthcare Agent Decisions ADIValueSetHealthcareAgentDecision ADI-ValueSet-HealthcareAgentDecision ADI Value Set for Healthcare Agent Decision PADIHealthGoalsVS PADIHealthGoalsVS Health Goals ADIValueSetHealthGoal ADI-ValueSet-HealthGoal ADI Value Set for Health Goal PADIInterventionPreferencesNarrativeVS PADIInterventionPreferencesNarrativeVS Intervention Preferences - Narrative ADIValueSetInterventionPreferenceNarrative ADI-ValueSet-InterventionPreferenceNarrative ADI Value Set for Intervention Preference Narrative PADIInterventionPreferencesOrdinalVS PADIInterventionPreferencesOrdinalVS Intervention Preferences - Ordinal ADIValueSetInterventionPreferenceOrdinal ADI-ValueSet-InterventionPreferenceOrdinal ADI Value Set for Intervention Preference Ordinal PADIInterventionPreferencesVS PADIInterventionPreferencesVS Intervention Preferences ADIValueSetInterventionPreference ADI-ValueSet-InterventionPreference ADI Value Set for Intervention Preference PADINoHealthcareAgentIncludedReasonVS PADINoHealthcareAgentIncludedReasonVS No Healthcare Agent Included Reason ADIValueSetNoHealthcareAgentIncludedReason ADI-ValueSet-NoHealthcareAgentIncludedReason ADI Value Set for No Healthcare Agent Included Reason PADIParticipantRelationshipVS PADIParticipantRelationshipVS Participant Relationships ADIValueSetParticipantRelationship ADI-ValueSet-ParticipantRelationship ADI Value Set for Participant Relationship PADIPersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleTypeVS PADIPersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleTypeVS Personal And Legal Relationship Role Type ADIValueSetPersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleType ADI-ValueSet-PersonalAndLegalRelationshipRoleType ADI Value Set for Personal And Legal Relationship Role Type PADIUponDeathPreferencesVS PADIUponDeathPreferencesVS Upon Death Preferences ADIValueSetUponDeathPreferences ADI-ValueSet-UponDeathPreferences ADI Value Set for Upon Death Preferences eSystem/PADIGoalCategoryCS eSystem/PADIGoalCategoryCS ADI Goal Category Code System ADICodeSystemGoalCategory ADI-CodeSystem-GoalCategory ADI Code System for Goal Category PADIHCADecisionsCS PADIHCADecisionsCS Healthcare Agent Decision Codes ADICodeSystemHealthcareAgentDecision ADI-CodeSystem-HealthcareAgentDecision ADI Code System for Healthcare Agent Decision
    • Corey Spears/Virginia Lorenzi : 10-0-0
    • Correction
    • Non-compatible

    Description

      The current profile names are inconsistent. All PACIO ADI defined profiles should have "PACIO ADI" in the name, as well as the name of base Resource they are profiling. Recommend following the convention {IG Shorthand} {Resource} {Subtyping} E.g. "ADI Organ Donation" ->"PACIO ADI Goal for Organ Donation"

      Further, the names of the Profiles as listed in [1.10 ADI Profiles (Table)](http://hl7.org/fhir/us/pacio-adi/2022Jan/index.html#adi-profiles) are not consistent with the names listed in the [FHIR Artifacts page](http://hl7.org/fhir/us/pacio-adi/2022Jan/artifacts.html#fhir-artifacts). They should be the same throughout the IG

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            may_terry May Terry
            dvreeman Daniel Vreeman
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: