Uploaded image for project: 'FHIR Specification Feedback'
  1. FHIR Specification Feedback
  2. FHIR-40742

Remove US Core QuestionnaireResponse Tags Element

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Icon: Change Request Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive
    • Icon: Medium Medium
    • US Core (FHIR)
    • 5.0.1
    • Cross-Group Projects
    • Terminology
    • Hide

      1) Remove the MS on meta.tag and the US Core Tags ValueSet
      2) Remove the QuestionnaireResponse tag SeachParameter combo from the SHOULD in the QuickStart and Capstatement
      3) Add guidance to use `Questionnaire.useContext` with a useContext with code="focus" and valueCodeableConcept of SDOH/functionalStatus/etc.

      • this context could includes all the USCDI contexts for assessments which are defined in US Core Category which Simple Observation and Screening and Assessments Observation currently use.
        • sdoh
        • functional-status
        • disability-status
        • cognitive-status

       

      Searching for all QRs for a patient whose Questionnaire has a specific context could be accomplished using a chained search:

      GET [base]/QuestionnaireResponse?subject=Patient/123&questionnaire.context-type-value=focus$sdoh

      4) provide examples

      Show
      1) Remove the MS on meta.tag and the US Core Tags ValueSet 2) Remove the QuestionnaireResponse tag SeachParameter combo from the SHOULD in the QuickStart and Capstatement 3) Add guidance to use `Questionnaire.useContext` with a useContext with code="focus" and valueCodeableConcept of SDOH/functionalStatus/etc. this context could includes all the USCDI contexts for assessments which are defined in US Core Category which Simple Observation and Screening and Assessments Observation currently use. sdoh functional-status disability-status cognitive-status   Searching for all QRs for a patient whose Questionnaire has a specific context could be accomplished using a chained search: GET [base] /QuestionnaireResponse?subject=Patient/123&questionnaire.context-type-value=focus$sdoh 4) provide examples
    • Eric Haas / Floyd Eisenberg : 12-0-0
    • Enhancement
    • Compatible, substantive
    • Yes

    Description

      Background

      Based on FHIR-39495, US Core will keep the version 5.0.1 US Core QuestionnaireResponse Profile.  This profile has a must support on `meta.tag` to indicate context like "sdoh" with a binding to US Core Tags ValueSet. The intent of this element was to mimic a category element like `Observation.category` without adding an extension to support filtering and searching by category. However this MS element is problematic since meta.tags are server-specific and not expected to span servers like category elements such as `Observation.category`.

       

      In version 6, we recommend supporting both SDC Questionnaire and US Core QuestionnaireResponse Profiles and since the context is typically provided by the Questionnaire (specifically using `Questionnaire.useContext`).

      Proposal

      1) Remove the MS on meta.tag and the US Core Tags ValueSet
      2) Remove the QuestionnaireResponse tag SeachParameter combo from the SHOULD in the QuickStart and Capstatement
      3) Add guidance to use `Questionnaire.useContext` with a useContext with code="focus" and valueCodeableConcept of SDOH/functionalStatus/etc.

      • this context could includes all the USCDI contexts for assessments which are defined in US Core Category which Simple Observation and Screening and Assessments Observation currently use.
        • sdoh
        • functional-status
        • disability-status
        • cognitive-status

       

      Searching for all QRs for a patient whose Questionnaire has a specific context could be accomplished using a chained search:

      GET [base]/QuestionnaireResponse?subject=Patient/123&questionnaire.context-type-value=focus$sdoh

      4) provide examples

       
      Note:

      • useContext is not part of the SDC Base Questionnaire Profile, and we are not proposing a new Questionnaire Profile
      • this is not a breaking change, but search functionality may not be supported in future versions.
         

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            Unassigned Unassigned
            ehaas Eric Haas
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: