Details
-
Change Request
-
Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
-
Medium
-
Shorthand (FHIR)
-
0.12.0 [deprecated]
-
FHIR Infrastructure
-
Normative
-
Language Reference
-
3.3.1
-
-
Mark Kramer / Rick Geimer : 16 - 0 - 1
-
Clarification
-
Non-substantive
-
Yes
Description
FSH has a formal grammar defined in ANTLR4. The grammar is looser than the language specification since many things, such as datatype agreement, are not enforced by the grammar. If there is discrepancy between the grammar and the FSH language description, the language description is considered correct until the discrepancy is clarified and addressed.
What does this mean? This sounds like a FHIR Version dependent extra layer of shorthand. Can we extract that out, e.g. in a separate section or appendix?
A shorthand expression could than be compliant shorthand but not matching a specific FHIR version. In potential, this would allow shorthand to be used for other domain models that use the FHIR structure definition mechanism.
Attachments
Issue Links
- is voted on by
-
BALLOT-21051 Negative - Bas van den Heuvel : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-22471 Negative - David Simons : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-22500 Negative - Ana Kostadinovska : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-22529 Negative - Chris Melo : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-22558 Negative - Timon Grob : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-22613 Negative - Ricardo Quintano : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-22642 Negative - Javier Espina : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Withdrawn
-
BALLOT-22442 Negative - Martin Rosner : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Closed
-
BALLOT-46173 Negative - Martin Rosner : 2021-Sep-FHIR IG SHORTHAND R2 Norm
- Closed